Ice Cream Pie Recipes (2024)

There is nothing like a good ice cream pie recipe when you need a quick and easy recipe for dessert. I have made these with both store-bought ice cream and no churn homemade ice cream and they always come out delicious.

I have been making ice cream pies for years, but I must say they have evolved as more layers and toppings are now making for drool-worthy ice cream pies on food sites. If you have never tried home-made ice cream, you really should! We just made this easy no-churn ice cream recipe.

Oh and did I mention that it is National Ice Cream Pie day on Thursday? Well it is, but not that we really need an excuse to make one of these. All you need is a crust and some ice cream and a freezer. But it is much more fun if you add other flavors. Now is the perfect time to make a lovely peach ice cream in your freezer.

I hope you all are enjoying the summer as we are. We had a wonderful time celebrating the 4th and watching fireworks last weekend in Paso Robles. This was our table decor. We didn't win the contest but it was still so much fun! Today I am sharing some easy ice cream pie recipes for a fun weekend potluck or picnic. Don't forget to keep things cool when on the go. This insulated picnic bag is perfect for a frozen pie.

Tips for Ice Cream Pies

Now is the best time for summer ice cream recipes so today we are sharing some fun ice cream pie recipes for you to enjoy the season with family and friends. Here you will find some Ice Cream Pie Recipes with Graham Cracker crusts, cookie crusts and even some made with a cereal crust.

Remember, you can always use store-bought ice cream and if you really are out of time, you can buy a premade crust too! But I think you will find that these are pretty darn easy to put together and the combinations are seriously endless!

Be sure to check out our othereasy ice cream recipes that are great for ice cream pies:

Red White and Blue Ice Cream– Made with strawberries and blueberries for a Patriotic treat.

Tropical No Churn Ice Cream– A delightful pineapple and coconut dessert that is wonderfully creamy and delicious.

Strawberry Kiwi No Churn Ice Cream– fresh strawberries and kiwis come together to make this colorful, tasty dessert combination.

25 Ice Cream Pie Recipes

1. Oreo Ice Cream Pie at The Baker Mama
2. Mississippi Mud Ice Cream Pie at Six Sister’s Stuff
3. Chocolate Candy Bar Ice Cream Pie at Chocolate, Chocolate and More
4. Raspberry Ice Cream Pie at Butter with a Side of Bread
5. Pumpkin Ice Cream Pie at Two Peas and their Pod
6. Peanut Butter Rice Krispie Ice Cream Pie at The Sugar Hit
7. Banana Split Ice Cream Pie at Will Cook for Smiles
8. Blueberry Coconut Ice Cream Pie at Blahnik Baker
9. Banana Cream Pie Ice Cream at Lady Behind the Curtain
10. Cinnamon Bun Ice Cream Pie at Ready to Yumble
11. Berries and Cream Ice Cream Pie at Joy Filled Eats
12. Chocolate-Raspberry Ice Cream Pie at Delish
13. Funfetti Cookie Dough Ice Cream Pie at Beyond Frosting
14. Caramel Toffee Ice Cream Pie at Ashley Marie
15. Frozen Turtle Pie at Southern Plate
16. Coffee Toffee Ice Cream Pie at Eat at Home
17. Oatmeal Cream Pie Ice Cream Pie at Beyond Frosting
18. Salted Caramel Ice Cream Pie with Miso Caramel Apples at Nada Moo
19. Gone Fishin’ S’mores Ice Cream Pie at Hostess at Heart
20. Chocolate Chip Cookie Crusted Cookie Dough Ice Cream Pie at Wine and Glue
21. Oreo and Heath Ice Cream Pie at Chin Deep
22. Banana Split Ice Cream Pie (in a jar!) at Around My Family Table
23. Drumstick Ice Cream Pie at The View from Great Island
24. Easy Mint Chip Cream Pie at The Cookie Rookie
25. Easy Peanut Butter Cup Ice Cream Pie at Cookie Rookie

Which one of these ice cream pie recipes do youwant totry first?