The BEST Cream Cheese Frosting Recipe + how to add different flavors (2024)

This is definitely the BEST cream cheese frosting recipe. It’s silky smooth, holds its shape, and can be used for just about anything. Pipe it on top of cupcakes, cover a layer cake, spread on a sheet cake, or frost sugar cookies. I’ve also included troubleshooting tips and instructions on how to customize your cream cheese frosting to any flavor or color.

Tips for making cream cheese frosting

This is a really simple recipe made up of only 4 ingredients, but just because it’s simple doesn’t mean we can cut corners! Here are my top tips to ensure yours turns out perfectly smooth:

1. Use good quality full fat cream cheese. I recommend using Philadelphia cream cheese as I find it provides the BEST texture. Any other brand, especially store brand, tends to make this frosting a bit too thin with tiny lumps throughout. It also doesn’t provide the best flavor. I don’t know what they put in Philadelphia cream cheese to make it so good, but it’s an absolute must for me! Side note – this is not sponsored, I just genuinely only ever use Philadelphia cream cheese for this exact reason.
2. Use unsalted butter. Since the cream cheese is already tangy and savory, additional salt is not needed. And since you have to pay a bit more for good quality cream cheese, you can make up for it with using store brand butter. I find it doesn’t make a difference whether it’s fancy butter or basic inexpensive butter.
3. Allow both to come to room temperature. This is KEY to getting a silky smooth cream cheese frosting. Let the cream cheese and butter sit out at room temperature for about 1-2 hours before use. When they’re ready, you should be able to easily sink your finger into each. Room temperature cream cheese and butter is easier to mix, giving you a lump-free frosting.
4. Use an electric stand mixer with the paddle attachment. You can also use a hand mixer, but a stand mixer makes this recipe much easier. I find it gives me the most consistent texture without whipping too much air into the frosting. Plus, the paddle is hefty and sturdy so it cuts right through the softened cream cheese and butter without clumping up.

How do you stiffen cream cheese frosting?

One of the most common questions I get is how to achieve a cream cheese frosting that’s smooth but still able to hold firm, especially when piping on cupcakes or spreading between layers of cake. The solution is actually very easy and works every time. But here are a few reasons why yours could turn out too thin in the first place:

1. Either reduced fat or low quality cream cheese was used. Full fat cream cheese is essential. It’s how you achieve a thick frosting because of, well, it’s high fat content. Reduced fat cream cheese tends to be a bit watered down, creating a thinner consistency. As far as brand, like I mentioned before, only use Philadelphia full fat cream cheese when possible. Other brands of cream cheese don’t have that perfect balance of gums in the ingredients, so they won’t allow the frosting to thicken and hold its shape like Philadelphia does.
2. Your cream cheese and/or butter was TOO soft before use. I know it’s tempting to stick them in the microwave to soften, but this causes the two to heat up too quickly, creating a melty and runny consistency on the outside but still firm on the inside. These melty portions are what thin out the frosting. If you didn’t use the microwave, it could just be that they were left out for too long, therefore softened too much.

Luckily there’s a remedy for both of these! Although if you used the wrong type of cream cheese, you may still have trouble getting the frosting to the right thickness.

If you used all the right ingredients and followed the recipe to a T and STILL came up with a thin frosting, simply place the bowl in the refrigerator for about 30 minutes to thicken. Yep, it’s that easy. As it chills, the butter and cream cheese will firm up to create a sturdy frosting that’s ready to pipe or spread on to any cake.

How to frost a layer cake with cream cheese frosting

Another major issue I hear quite often is how difficult it is to use cream cheese frosting on layer cakes. Many of you claim that your cakes slide around and just will not stay put. I get it, I’ve been there! So here’s a really simple solution to ensure your cream cheese layer cakes turn out just right:

1. First, follow my instructions above on how to thicken the frosting. If you’re having trouble with it sliding around on your cake, it could be that it’s too thin in the first place.
2. Once it’s chilled, also make sure your cakes are COMPLETELY cooled before use. Even the slightest warmth will cause the frosting to melt and slip. To ensure they’re chilled, I recommend storing them in the refrigerator overnight or for at least 3 hours before use.
3. Don’t spread too much frosting between each cake layer. Spread enough to where you can’t see the cake poking through, but not too much to where it squishes out when you place another cake layer on top. If you spread a layer that’s too thick, you’ll have a hard time keeping the cake in place.
4. Once you’ve spread the frosting between each cake layer, chill the cake for about 30-45 minutes before continuing. While the cake chills, chill the bowl of frosting as well. Then, take it out about 15 minutes before the cake to allow it to loosen up a bit. Chilling the cake before frosting the outside allow those layers to lock in place. Otherwise, they could shift as you press up against the sides of the cake with more frosting.
5. To lock everything in place, chill the cake right away once it’s covered in the frosting. Do so even before decorations. Chill for about 20 minutes to allow that frosting to thicken once again.

Now add your decorations on top and chill until your cake is ready to serve. The key to cream cheese frosting is to just keep it cold. Due to its high fat content, it tends to melt rapidly. So when it doubt, just stick it in the refrigerator!

How to make brown butter cream cheese frosting

Now comes the fun part. Using the base recipe at the bottom of this post, you can either leave it as is or customize it to your liking. First up, you can add a rich and nutty flavor by mixing in room temperature brown butter. Click here to learn all about how to brown butter.

It’s also very easy to do! Simply brown the 1 cup of butter in this recipe and then allow it to chill before use. You want it to be set but not rock hard, just like room temperature butter. Once the butter is browned, pour it into a shallow dish and chill for about 1 hour. It should solidify but still be easy to dig a knife into. Then, treat the rest of the frosting recipe the exact same.

To see brown butter cream cheese frosting in action, check out my recipe for the BEST spice cake.

How to add fruit to cream cheese frosting

There are two different ways you can approach this. If you plan to use a fruity cream cheese frosting on a dessert like a sheet cake (such as the strawberry cake below), one that doesn’t require the frosting to be super thick and sturdy, you can use fresh fruit.

Simply mix in 1/4 cup of pureed fruit for every 8 oz of cream cheese. Then, add another 2 cups of powdered sugar for every 8 oz of cream cheese, on top of the already existing 2 1/2 cups. This will balance out the tartness of the fruit and help thicken up the frosting.

The second option is to add 1/4 cup of blended freeze dried fruit for every 8oz of cream cheese. No additional sugar is needed as the freeze dried fruit is like a powder. This small amount will also add tons of color to your frosting. The pros of using freeze dried fruit is that the frosting can now be used for any dessert as it will hold its shape well.

How to make chocolate cream cheese frosting

Transforming it into chocolate frosting is quick, easy, and only requires one extra ingredient. After you’ve mixed in all the powdered sugar, add 3/4 cup of dark cocoa powder and mix until smooth. You’ll use 3/4 cup for every 16oz of cream cheese. So if you only use half this recipe, you’ll then need 6 tbsp of cocoa powder (which is half of 3/4 cup).

You can use this frosting for anything, whether that’s a layer cake, sheet cake, or cupcakes. Below is a photo of my extra moist chocolate sheet cake with chocolate cream cheese frosting spread on top.

How to add color to cream cheese frosting

Cream cheese frosting and sugar cookies is a match made in heaven. You get the sweet and buttery cookie paired with the slightly tangy but extra creamy frosting. But to make it a bit more fun, here’s how you can add color:

1. Do not use liquid food coloring. You need a lot of liquid coloring to get a decent color pay off. This liquid will thin out your frosting and make it much too runny. Instead, use gel food coloring. You only need a couple drops to color the frosting. Here is the brand I use.
2. Mixing in the food coloring is additional friction that slightly heats up the frosting. This makes it a bit softer, so chill the frosting before use. If you’ve separated it into small dishes, only chill for 15-20 minutes. If you’re coloring an entire bowl of frosting with just one color, chill the bowl for 30-45 minutes.

Now it’s ready to spread or pipe on top of any dessert! Below you can see this colorful cream cheese frosting in action on my perfect cut out sugar cookies.

How to add cinnamon to cream cheese frosting

One last customization is to add some spice to your frosting. My favorite pairing is cream cheese and cinnamon which I used on my gingerbread cupcakes. For every 8oz of cream cheese, add 1/2 teaspoon of cinnamon.

How long can cream cheese frosting be refrigerated?

It will keep in the refrigerator for about 2 weeks. This is if the bowl is tightly covered in plastic wrap.

To revive it, let it sit at room temperature for about an hour. Then give it a good mix to loosen it up. Now it’s ready to use!

Knowing the amount of frosting needed for different recipes

Layer cakes – The recipe shown in the recipe card at the bottom of this post is the right amount for a 3-layer 6, 8, or 9 inch layer cake. For 6 inch, you’ll have enough leftover to pipe swirls on top. For 8 inch or more, it’s enough to cover the entire cake but not enough excess to decorate with.

Cupcakes – If you need cream cheese frosting for a cupcake recipe, cut this frosting recipe in half (see below for measurements). It’s enough to top 12 cupcakes.

Sheet cake – For a 9×13 sheet cake, you’ll only need half of this recipe (see below for measurements).

Cookies – If you want to frost sugar cookies, cut this recipe in half and it should be enough to cover 20-30 cookies. (see below for measurments)

HALF RECIPE

• 1/2 cup (110g) unsalted butter, room temp
• 8 oz full fat cream cheese, room temp
• 2 1/2 – 3 cups powdered sugar
• 1/4 tsp vanilla extract

Recipes where you can use this cream cheese frosting:

• Spice Cake with Brown Butter Cream Cheese Frosting
• BEST EVER Carrot Cake
• Gingerbread Cupcakes
• Cut Out Sugar Cookies
• Chocolate Sheet Cake
• Fresh Strawberry Sheet Cake
• Carrot Cake Cupcakes

Make sure to tag me @butternutbakery onInstagramand comment below if you make this cream cheese frosting. To pin this recipe and save it for later, you can use the button on the recipe card or on any of the photos above. Happy baking!

Print

Recipe Card powered by