‘They need more than rent’: Support at Safe Stay communities helps residents address problems, exit cycle of homelessness (2024)

News/Clark County News

Some Columbian readers have questioned costs of Vancouver's Safe Stay homeless shelters

ByAlexis Weisend, Columbianstaff reporter

Published: May 17, 2024, 6:07am

Updated: May 17, 2024, 3:56pm

4 Photos

‘They need more than rent’: Support at Safe Stay communities helps residents address problems, exit cycle of homelessness (1)

Several readers have contacted The Columbian to ask how much it costs to house someone at one of Vancouver’s four Safe Stay homeless shelters, each of which comprises 20 huts surrounded by a fence. Wouldn’t it be cheaper, they ask, to just pay each person’s rent?

True, the ongoing cost of the average hut in a Safe Stay is $1,956 a month — more than the average cost of apartment rent in Vancouver, according to estimates from listing sites. Acquiring and preparing each site costs about as much as the average house in Vancouver — $548,609.

But city staff say Safe Stays are the best response to Vancouver’s chronic homelessness problem because they provide support beyond just a roof over people’s heads.

“The argument that it would be cheaper to pay their rent is just not taking into account that they need more than rent,” said Jamie Spinelli, Vancouver’s homeless response manager.

The city declared homelessness to be a civil emergency in November in large part because people are staying homeless longer than ever, officials said. In 2018, 60 people were homeless for more than a year, according to the Point in Time Count, a federal effort to track the number of homeless people. In 2022, that number jumped to 223.

Moving directly from the street into housing might be a good option for some. But for others, that’s just setting them up to end up back on the street, Spinelli said. Many of the homeless people she encounters have been living on the street for years and struggle with addiction or mental health issues.

Spinelli said she’s met people who have cycled in and out of housing, receiving financial assistance with rent only to become evicted and homeless again when that help ends. Others bring their addiction into housing only to die alone from an overdose.

“No one wants people to move in and die,” she said.

The Safe Stays are an effort to help homeless people address their problems — whether they need help with their addiction, mental illness, employment or financial skills — before they get into housing so they can stay in that housing over the long term, Spinelli said.

Each Safe Stay has 20 units manufactured by the Everett company Pallet. And each of the Pallet sleeping shelters is 70 square feet and has room for two people. The privacy allowed in Safe Stay shelters draws interest from people who may not feel comfortable going to congregate shelters, Spinelli said.

“There are segments of the homeless population that kind of shelter does not work well for,” Spinelli said.

For example, men are separated from women and children in congregate shelters. Spinelli said the Safe Stays are the first shelters in Vancouver where couples can live together. The huts also can make LBGTQ+ people feel safer, she said.

A study earlier this year by Portland State University found that people living in pallet shelter communities are more likely to exit into housing than people in congregate shelters.

The Safe Stay shelters, as the name implies, are meant to be a safe place to stay while waiting for housing. They provide daily meals and support from people who have been through similar experiences, Spinelli said.

That’s part of the reason it costs more than an apartment to operate a single pallet shelter each month, said Brian Norris. He’s the executive director of the nonprofit Live Love Outreach, which runs the city’s second Safe Stay called Hope Village, which opened in April 2022.

The nonprofit has a contract with the city for $528,154 to run Hope Village for a second year.

He said the nonprofit uses that money to staff the communities 24/7, pay caseworkers who help people address their various issues and provide meals. The funds also pay for laundry cards, bus passes, bathroom supplies and cleaning products.

Although he understands why some people would rather the money for Safe Stays go toward rent, Norris said people who have lived on the streets for years often lose the life skills necessary for consistently paying rent.

“I get the benefit of it — getting roofs over people’s heads — but if there’s no accountability, if there’s no structure, then you’re just kind of enabling people to continue that lifestyle,” Norris said. “We’re teaching those skills.”

Editor’s note: This article has been updated with the correct monthly estimate of a Pallet shelter.

This story was made possible by Community Funded Journalism, a project from The Columbian and the Local Media Foundation. Top donors include the Ed and Dollie Lynch Fund, Patricia, David and Jacob Nierenberg, Connie and Lee Kearney, Steve and Jan Oliva, The Cowlitz Tribal Foundation and the Mason E. Nolan Charitable Fund. The Columbian controls all content. For more information, visit columbian.com/cfj.

‘They need more than rent’: Support at Safe Stay communities helps residents address problems, exit cycle of homelessness (2024)


What is the best solution for homelessness? ›

Housing-Based Solutions

Numerous research studies have consistently confirmed that long-term housing assistance not only successfully reduces homelessness — it is also less expensive than shelter and other institutional care.

What is the most effective program for homelessness? ›

For the minority of individuals who are chronically homeless and have serious physical or mental health challenges, supportive housing — or permanent housing paired with case management and support services — is an approach that research shows is effective in enabling individuals to exit homelessness and achieve ...

Is homelessness a negative externality? ›

The homeless as negative externalities

The perception of uncompensated cost which defines them as negative externalities is socially produced.

What is the Boulder homelessness strategy? ›

Boulder employs a multi-pronged approach to try to get more people into housing. Through sheltering, outreach coordination and homeless navigation services, the city attempts to reach people experiencing homelessness and connect them with services.

What are three solutions to homelessness? ›

The core components of rapid re-housing are: FIND housing – help people quickly find housing. PAY for housing – help people pay for housing short term. STAY in housing – help access services so people can stay in housing.

What is the easiest solution to homelessness? ›

Housing as the Solution

The solution to homelessness is simple – housing. Rapid re-housing is an intervention designed to quickly connect people to housing and services.

What states have the best homeless programs? ›

Key findings: Colorado ranked the top state in the nation for housing assistance from 2018 to 2019. Connecticut saw a 23.6% decline in homelessness from 2018 to 2019. In 2019, it was estimated that nearly 568,000 were experiencing homelessness.

Why is it hard for homeless to get a job? ›

Basic requirements such as having an address, an ID, a birth certificate, and professional clothing are often out of reach or not easily obtainable for people experiencing homelessness.

Which state has the most homeless? ›

Data is based on point-in-time count that occurred during January 2023. In terms of raw numbers, California had the highest number of people experiencing homelessness of any state: 181,399. New York had the nation's second-most with 103,200, followed by Florida with 30,756.

Is homelessness good or bad? ›

For many people, living on the streets of California is a death sentence. That's according to a recent study that took the first deep look into mortality rates in homeless communities throughout the country. It found the death rate more than tripled between 2011 and 2020.

What makes homelessness bad? ›

People experiencing homelessness have an increased risk of having poor health and prolonged illness. Additionally, living outdoors and in crowded areas can lead to health issues. The homeless population also lacks general wellness care. Crowded shelters and sleeping outdoors make it difficult to ward off illnesses.

What is the biggest problem with homelessness? ›


Those that become unhoused are frequently rent-burdened, live paycheckto-paycheck, and many report suffering from serious mental illness or substance abuse issues.

How to solve Los Angeles homelessness? ›

We need to expand rental protections and housing subsidy programs, including rental assistance for people at risk of eviction, housing vouchers, and broader financial support for people experiencing homelessness who are transitioning into housing.

What is California doing to prevent homelessness? ›

Between 2018-2021, California invested $9.6 billion in programs to expand affordable housing and invest in programs to serve those experiencing homelessness. The Homekey program has allocated almost $2 billion to create nearly 7,000 homes since 2021.

What is California doing to reduce homelessness? ›

SAN FRANCISCO — Nearly $200 million in grant money will go to California cities and counties to move homeless people from encampments into housing, Gov. Gavin Newsom announced Thursday while also pledging increased oversight of efforts by local governments to reduce homelessness.

Why should homelessness be solved? ›

Homelessness Affects All of Us

It impacts the availability of healthcare resources, crime and safety, the workforce, and the use of tax dollars. Further, homelessness impacts the present as well as the future. It benefits all of us to break the cycle of homelessness, one person, one family at a time.

How to not end up homeless? ›

You possibly can avoid becoming homeless by learning about and accessing prevention or emergency assistance programs in your area. Often these programs provide help paying rent, utilities, or bills; although the availability of resources can be limited.

How to solve the housing crisis in the US? ›

While it's important to enforce discipline and fairness in the system, the main goal should be to ensure an adequate supply of affordable housing for all. This means looking at local zoning laws, leveraging public-private partnerships, and making a long-term commitment to solving the problem. There are no quick fixes.

How does Japan deal with homelessness? ›

In Japan, it is almost illegal to beg or sleep on the streets. Cities such as Tokyo are known for their anti-homeless or hostile architecture. Many parks in Tokyo are being locked at night to keep homeless people from sleeping there or hiring security guards to take them out.

Top Articles
Latest Posts
Article information

Author: Stevie Stamm

Last Updated:

Views: 5899

Rating: 5 / 5 (80 voted)

Reviews: 95% of readers found this page helpful

Author information

Name: Stevie Stamm

Birthday: 1996-06-22

Address: Apt. 419 4200 Sipes Estate, East Delmerview, WY 05617

Phone: +342332224300

Job: Future Advertising Analyst

Hobby: Leather crafting, Puzzles, Leather crafting, scrapbook, Urban exploration, Cabaret, Skateboarding

Introduction: My name is Stevie Stamm, I am a colorful, sparkling, splendid, vast, open, hilarious, tender person who loves writing and wants to share my knowledge and understanding with you.